Don’t Visit Ontonagon

Move along; there’s nothing to see here.

Just a village of about 1400 people located where the Ontonagon river spills into Lake Superior at the western foot of the Keweenaw peninsula. It’s not just sleepy; it’s practically catatonic.

A hundred years ago, Ontonagon bustled with lumber, paper, and shipbuilding industries. It had an active deep-water port where Great Lakes freighters delivered coal to the paper mill as recently as the 2010s. But by the time I pulled onto the main drag for the first time in June 2020, the town was so quiet a dog could sleep in the middle of River Street all afternoon and never have to get up to avoid a car. I put the lack of activity on the street down to COVID closures, but six years later, I’m still visiting, and it’s still almost that quiet.

Don’t expect interesting shopping here. A couple of stores operate on River Street, catering to special interests like rock collecting (agates can be found locally) or folk music. Porcupine Mountain State Park, 15 minutes west, runs a folk school in the summer and there are a lot of musicians associated with it. The hardware store does a good business in camping supplies, but the busiest retailer is the St. Vincent de Paul store.

Few people try starting a business here. A couple of years ago a pair of Delta Airlines retirees moved up from Atlanta and tried opening a coffeeshop on River Street—the kind you find in hip college towns, not the kind with a table where old men gather and solve the world’s problems. But the couple wasn’t consistent about open hours; the townfolk got mad and quit patronizing them, and they sold it. It’s uncertain if the new owners will hang on.

Not much interesting dining here either. There is no food that didn’t come in on the Sysco truck. The closest thing to an ethnic restaurant is the microwaveable burritos from the gas station. Oh sure, you can get pizza or a pasty at Syl’s Cafe. Pasties, a meaty hand-held pie brought by the copper miners who were the first Europeans here, is the traditional ethnic food of Ontonagon. But most diners come to River Street for a beer and a sandwich at Roxey’s Pub, or a beer and no sandwich at Stubbs Bar. They have taxidermy instead of a grill.

What is there to do here? Nothing but enjoy the nature, actively or passively, your choice. Porcupine Mountains Wilderness State Park covers roughly 60,000 acres. Of that, 35,000 acres are old-growth forest. The park has over 20 miles of lakeshore and a number of rivers rushing into Lake Superior. The height difference between the highest peak and the shore is approximately 1400 feet; the drop makes for some exceptionally dramatic scenery at the many waterfalls in early spring, when the snowmelt turns them into sparkling fairy castles. Every backyard has a canoe or kayak or two in it. Most have some ATVs or UTVs as well.

Most of the locals choose to live here because they love their outdoor recreation. But most prefer fall and winter; spring comes late and should properly be called mud season. Summer is a brief season when the population of biting insects—mosquitoes, deerflies, blackflies—outnumber the tourists, and going outdoors takes massive preparation with head-to-toe clothing made of netting and a dose of DEET for good measure. If you take precautions, you can enjoy the over 90 miles of trails in the park. The rangers ask that you leave a note on your dash telling where you’re planning to go and when you’re planning to be back—people get lost that often.

Fall brings hunting and leaf-peeping. Winter brings the real fun—for the silent sports types, cross-country and downhill skiing or snowshoeing. For the power sports crowd, snowmobiles come out of storage: Ontonagon County is home to more than 350 miles of groomed snowmobile trails.

Me, I stick to the quiet activities—hiking and swimming in summer, snowshoeing in winter. I’ve had my peak moments: I’ve lain in my down coat on my back on the frozen beach in January, watching the Pleiades meteor shower, as Northern Lights surge over the big lake. I’ve clambered on the frozen moonscape of ice, driven ashore and packed into strange formations by the strong winds of early spring. On a steamy summer day I’ve waded into the 50-degree water,  thrilling to the heart-stopping slaps on my torso as I breast the waves rolling ashore. I’ve gazed over miles of stunning October foliage from the Lake of the Clouds trail as tourists from around the world surge around me. I’ve stood deep in the woods next to tip-ups taller than my head, where giants of the forest four feet in diameter lay in rows like fallen soldiers, felled by a particularly devastating windstorm. I’ve contemplated what this landscape looked like before the first lumbermen arrived.

But why am I telling you this? I don’t want you to fall for Ontonagon like I did. I don’t want anything there to change. I want it to stay forever a place where the only thing to do is to appreciate the natural world, and a dog can sleep in the middle of River Street all day.

© 2026 Sarah White

Unknown's avatar

About first person productions

My blog "True Stories Well Told" is a place for people who read and write about real life. I’ve been leading life writing groups since 2004. I teach, coach memoir writers 1:1, and help people publish and share their life stories.
This entry was posted in Sarah's memoir. Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to Don’t Visit Ontonagon

  1. Marg's avatar Marg says:

    Hey Sarah, Sounds like my kind of town. Good for book reading & a coffee where you can say, I’ll have black coffee, rather than having to ask in Italian or Latin or whatever. Only one thing I’d suggest: drop the DDT (illegal since the ’70s) and go for the DEET.

Leave a Reply